Thursday, October 30, 2025

Why did my teeth shift after the braces came off? Part 3: unfavorable growth.

 

Why did my teeth shift after the braces came off?

I often hear from patients that their teeth moved after their braces came off and they want to know why.  There are basically 3 reasons for a failed case (that was treated well.)

1. The patient did not wear their retainers properly. This is patient error.

2. The patient did not eliminate mouth habits, and did not wear appliances to protect them from their mouth habits. This is a combination of patient and dentist error (if the dentist did not make the patient aware of their habits, and/or did not make appliances that could protect the patient from these habits.)

3. The patient grew unfavorably. No one had control over this one. 

(4. If the teeth were not aligned in the middle of the bone ridge, they will relapse to be centered in the ridge again. The treating dentist had control over this reason.)

The next few blogs will address these errors. Today we will address #3: unfavorable growth.

Unfavorable growth is the growth that takes place after the braces are removed which destroys the final bite. One jaw grows more than the other. The teeth in each jaw may stay perfectly aligned, but the bones that support the teeth may not stay in balance with each other. 

We can all see that children look like their parents.  Facial balance is also genetically determined. Parents with “buck teeth” have children with “buck teeth”; Parents with “underbites” have children with “underbites.” Although we can change the skeletal balance and esthetics with orthodontic orthopedics in young patients, the patients continue to grow after their active orthodontic treatment is complete.    A patient who started with their front teeth sticking out “way too far” will relapse in that direction- their top jaw will continue growing and after several years they may have front teeth that stick out farther than when they completed treatment. This relapse growth issue is seen most vividly in “underbite” cases. The bottom jaw will continue growing for many years after the top jaw stops growing, so a patient who started with a prominent lower jaw will continue growing that prominent lower jaw and the lower jaw may “outgrow” the balance that had been achieved with the orthodontic orthopedic treatment. In addition, lower jaw bones rotate internally, although the outside remodels and looks the same.  The lower front teeth  tip forward with this rotation and in order to stay behind the upper teeth, the lower teeth develop "middle age crowding."

The skull, like the rest of the body, shows early growth “high up” and later growth “low down.”  We see this in babies who have large skulls with respect to the rest of the body versus adults who have small skulls with respect to the rest of the body.  The skull stops growing earlier than the legs stop growing.  Within the skull, the top of the face stops growing earlier than the bottom of the face. The midface stops growing earlier than the lower face.  With orthodontic orthopedics (palatal expansion with headgear treatment) we can modify the growth of the maxilla (upper jaw), which is in the mid-face. Palatal expansion is successful in girls until about age 12, and in boys until about age 14, when the midface stops growing.  While creating width of the upper jaw (palatal expansion) forces can be exerted on the jaw to restrain the growth (traditional straight pull headgear to the top of the head and the back of the neck) or to increase the amount of growth in the forward direction (with front pull headgear against the forehead and chin.) These treatments are no longer effective after the midface has finished growing because the sutures (the zippers between the bones) close with physical maturity. The mandible (the lower jaw which is in the lower third of the face) continues to grow for many more years than the maxilla (upper jaw bone), until about age 17 in girls, and until about age 23 in boys.  If the mandible was genetically programmed to be small, we do not notice the forward growth of the mandible after the maxilla stops growing.  If the mandible was genetically programmed to be large, the forward growth of the mandible is obvious and often results in a return of the “underbite.” 

When I treat “underbite” cases I overcorrect the forward correction of the maxilla, leaving the young patients with the opposite problem from which they presented.  They start with the upper teeth and jaw behind the lower teeth and jaw, and I finish them with the upper teeth and jaw too far forward for the lower teeth and jaw. An ideal bite has the upper front teeth one to two millimeters in front of the lower front teeth.  A Class III underbite may have the upper front teeth behind or tip to tip to the lower front teeth.  I overcorrect the jaw position leaving the upper teeth three to four millimeters in front of the lower teeth in order to allow for up to 2mm more lower jaw growth in the future.  I do not aim for a correction of over-jet to 5mm because I do not want to take the risk that the lower jaw does not have a late growth spurt, and the final result (as an adult) remains with excessive over-jet (seen as “buck teeth.”) Anticipating how much relapse growth will take place is an educated guess based on family history and the appearance of the parents.

Another phenomenon, related to unfavorable growth is the relapse of tooth rotations and teeth that grew in to the outside or inside of the arch form.  The longer the teeth “live” in the poor position, the more they have ingrained that “memory” of that position.  If the size of the arch form is corrected early and the teeth grow into a straight position, the teeth are more likely to stay in a straight position.  If the jaw size is corrected and the teeth aligned within a year after the teeth erupt, the teeth are more likely to stay in a straight position.  If the jaw size is corrected as an early teenager, the teeth already have a memory of the crooked position, and are more likely to return to that crooked position after orthodontic treatment has been completed.  If the teeth are aligned in adults, after facial growth is complete, the teeth are much more likely to return to the crooked position.  This is why night time retainer wear is so important in patients whose teeth were aligned later in life.

No comments: